THONET

THURSDAY 30 OCTOBER 2014

SEARCH   
 
 
WAN Mobile
 
WAN Mobile
Previous Next
 
Wangjing SOHO / Meiquan 22nd Century, China 
Monday 07 Jan 2013
 
The sincerest form of flattery? 
 
Wangjing SOHO by Zaha Hadid Architects 
 
Your comments on this project

No. of Comments: 3

Add comments | More comments

09/01/13 Keith Fielder RIBA, London
For hundreds if not thousands of years architects have been copying, been inspired by and designed 'in the manner of ' other architects' works, poring through magazines searching for the best bits to use. Clients also do this, taking their magazines to the architects and demanding 'something like this'. To what extent copying, imitation and flattery become plagiarism will have to be decided if the case goes to law. An exercise that might be very expensive, time consuming and in the end unproductive. Ms. Hadid does not have intellectual rights to curvy buildings. Her very beautiful design bears some resemblance to Pacific Place in Hong Kong which she might have seen a long time ago.
Ms. Hadid's own web page describes the concept as based on 'Chinese fans that circle and embrace each other in an intricate embrace'. Very nice but different from Koi which are carp fish swimming in a pool.
Click for more ...
09/01/13 Keith Fielder RIBA, London
www.globaltimes.cn - "Case Builds against copycat architecture in China" shows other architectural copies for the education and amusement of your readers especially the Ronchamp Chapel by Le Corbusier now reincarnated as a barbecue restaurant.
09/01/13 Charles Crawford, Washington DC
This is interesting, Chinese corporations concerned about copyright and patent infringements. This is a first. Everyone should just relax and allow this ‘Suppository’ architecture to replicate.
 

Editorial

Time running out for Zaha Hadid project as 'pirates' replicate design of Wangjing SOHO 


As WAN reported earlier this week, the world’s most famous female architect is facing a case of plagiarism in China with her latest project in Beijing. Hadid’s design for the Wangjing SOHO scheme has allegedly been replicated in Chongqing and may be completed before her Beijing project which is due for completion in 2014.

China is no stranger to speedy construction projects with schemes such as the T30 Hotel at Dongting Lake, Hunan Province which shot up in 15 days and another 16-storey building also completed in Hunan Province, this time in an incredible 136 hours. This time however, the race is about more than just statistics.

Developer Chongqing Meiquan Properties Ltd is advertising units at its commercial property currently under construction on Jiangbei Haier Road at a cost of 42,000 Yuan per sq m. The property - known as Meiquan 22nd Century - is to be 85,000 sq m in total with renderings clearly showing two curved building volumes very similar to those designed by Hadid in Beijing.

Local press appear to have been aware of this replica design since May 2012 however the story has taken to the global stage in the last few days after it was suggested by Die Spiegel that Chongqing Meiquan Properties Ltd’s development may be completed before Hadid’s Wangjing SOHO project.

In May 2012, China Intellectual Property gave the following report: “On May 14 (2012), SOHO China and Chongqing Meiquan held press conferences respectively. Chongqing Meiquan, speaking with Chongqing dialect, stated that the design of Meiquan 22nd Century was inspired by the cobblestones on the bank of the Yangtze River by which Chongqing was built.

“However, Pan (Shiyi, Board Chairman of SOHO China) took a tough stance on this issue, saying that Wangjing SOHO was designed to reproduce the image of Koi, which symbolizes ‘wealth, luck, health and happiness’ in Chinese culture, and insisted on filing a lawsuit. He also thought that in order to guarantee the healthy development of China’s creative industry, it was necessary to protect creative ideas and IP rights in China.”

The report also alluded that Zaha Hadid Architects initiated legal proceedings against Chongqing Meiquan Properties Ltd. WAN was awaiting confirmation of this from the practice at the time of going to press.

Sian Disson
News Editor

Key Facts

Status Under construction
Value 0(m€)
Add your name to this project
Zaha Hadid Architects
www.zaha-hadid.com

More projects by this architect

Sleuk Rith

The David and Claudia Harding Mathematics Gallery, Science Museum

Crest

Tokyo Olympic Stadium

Jockey Club Innovation Tower

More Projects

 
Vola
ECOWAN
 

Click here to view the NEWS IN PICTURES tablet site