WAN Awards

WEDNESDAY 26 NOVEMBER 2014

SEARCH   
 
 
WAN Mobile
 
WAN Mobile
Previous Next
 
The Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth, Texas, United States 
Friday 28 May 2010
 
Adding to an 'I.Kahn’ 
 
Renzo Piano Building Workshop 
 
Your comments on this project

No. of Comments: 8

Add comments | More comments

12/10/10 Dave Tupper, AIA, Houston, TX
I tend to agree w/ the editorial. As an architect whose partially grew up in Fort Worth, the Kimball was key to forming my later professional direction. It seems that Piano's classicism and reverence might be better served by locating his building further south; instead of a mirror, it preserves most of the green directly in front of Kahn's building and serves as a front for his own addition on equal par w/ Kahn's. Handled well, such a space could end up being a third part as great as the building(s) it would front and connect.

I wonder if I might be missing something since no one else seems to have mentioned that location and orientation.
Click for more ...
05/10/10 chris, Ft Worth
I understand that many people feel the new building is not a good idea but all of you that feel that way should know that it IS a good thing. The new building will give everyone a chance to see the Kimbells entire collection. During exhibitions a majority of that is put into the valt. AND the majority of the grass and trees will be replaced since at least half of the new building will be under ground. There will also be a parking garage underground. Being a member I felt the same way when I first found out. Now after speaking to various people and seeing the model it seems like a VERY smart idea. It also looks like it will be a beautiful new building.
Click for more ...
02/06/10 Robert McCarter, St. Louis
The reader is correct on the orientation, which I got wrong in this quote (though not in my Kahn book). However, this does not change the basic concern I am expressing here regarding the deleterious impact on the experience of the Kimbell of the proposed Piano-designed addition in the park.
02/06/10 Alex Njoo, St. Kilda (Australia)
Notwithstanding McCarter's remarks on Piano's contribution, I'm particularly delighted to read (for once) an erudite piece of architectural reportage that leaves out the writer's presence. Too often people who write about architecture have tended to project themselves rather than the subject matter. I'm so pleased that WAN has avoided the trappings of the center-stage syndrome.
Click for more ...
02/06/10 Andrew Charles Yanoviak, AIA, Honolulu, Hawaii
Very important project with very interesting architectural design values; however, more graphical site planning presentation is required to balance the verbal textual information; e.g., suggest that you show the reflecting pool plan, existing and proposed museum, vehicular and pedestrian traffic circulation, and overall landscaping architectural context; thereby, improving the level of critique.

Both authors David G. De Long and Robert McCarter are more than qualified to studiously comment; however, it would be helpful to reference a Master Plan to evaluate their critical site specific comments.

Sharon Mc Hugh's astute introductory commentary on the 'please or no please' vivid super-challenging counterbalancing act required of architect Piano and his associates is very much appreciated!
Click for more ...
02/06/10 Anurag Parmar, Washington DC
We have managed to destroy one of the great urban spaces in Fort Worth i.e. the grand green sward in front of the Kimbell. Why do we need another museum? The scale of the Kimbell was eminently appropriate for a museum. Making larger buildings force people to rush through the building trying to absorb as much as possible in a short time. The Kimbell's scale was and should remain the paradigm for regional museums.
Click for more ...
02/06/10 Jacques Gubler, Bale, CH
Sensible design in hommage to Kahn & his definition of architecture as institution.
01/06/10 JB, Fort Worth, Texas
How can we place any value in Robert McCarter"s comments? He clearly does not know that Ando's Modern Museum is to the east of the Kimball. Not to the Southwest. I guess college projects do not rigorously investigate the importance of a project site anymore.
I might also add; the arbor of trees is to the WEST side of the Kimball, Not to the north, as Mr McCarter states.
Click for more ...
 

Editorial

The Kimbell Art Museum unveils Piano-designed pavilion 

Adding to an 'I.Kahn’ The Kimbell Art Museum unveils Piano-designed pavilion Adding to an architectural masterpiece is a daunting task that it not for the faint of heart. Such work is fraught with difficulties and the environment is ripe for failure. The architect who is second on the scene operates from a precarious perch. Working in the shadow of a master he or she must find that happy middle ground between asserting one’s own voice and restating another’s. If the tenor of the new work is not pitch-perfect, the architect stands to be vilified. And if the new work strikes the right chord the architect will likely be called a genius. Regardless, these commissions come with high stakes — reputations are tested and designs are picked apart down to bare bone. So when the Kimball Art Museum in Fort Worth, Texas recently unveiled a new museum building, designed by Renzo Piano, naturally the art world took notice and observers began weighing in on the Italian architect’s proposal, which extends the Louis I. Kahn masterpiece by mirroring it in a wholly new structure facing it from across a reflecting pool.

For years, the Kimbell has operated under less than ideal circumstances. The museum’s programs have grown far beyond those envisioned when Kahn’s building opened in 1972. But the difficulty of adding to its icon thwarted its attempts to expand. In the 1980s, the Kimbell hired Romaldo Giurgola to expand Kahn’s building. But when Giurgola proposed replicating Kahn’s form-defining vaults, creating massive public outcry, the project was abandoned. In Renzo Piano the museum has architect with a sensitive touch and one who holds great buildings in high regard. His track record for designing great museums and for expanding landmark buildings is unparalleled among his peers. Piano’s addition to Meier’s High Museum in Atlanta received high marks, including from Meier. And, his addition to The Morgan Library, where he ingeniously added ’a piazza’ inside the building, imparting a new organization that allows the building to be seen afresh, has been critically appraised. Having worked with Kahn early in his career should help Piano, who considers the Kimbell to be “one of the best buildings in the world” and “the very best building by Kahn”.

While the praise for Piano’s work is generally quite high, there are those who have said, “Piano fatigue is setting in” in America where he has scooped up many of the country’s most prized commissions. If there is one knock against Piano, and it is a recurring one, it is that he is at times too referential for his own good. The New York Times architecture critic, Nicolai Ouroussoff, said of Piano’s recent proposal for the Isabelle Stewart Gardener Museum, that “if the design has a flaw it’s not that it tramples all over Gardner’s memory but that it holds it in too high a regard”.

Piano’s new building, which will break ground thissummer with completion in 2013, is actually two separate yet connected structures. The building doubles the museum’s gallery space, adds expanded educational and library space, and a new 290-seat auditorium. The project also provides underground parking for 137 cars. The siting of the building and the parking corrects the tendency of most visitors to enter the Kahn building from the rear. The building echoes Kahn’ building in its materials, scale and proportions as well as in its general plan and yet asserts its own more open transparent character. Both pavilions will be built of concrete, tripled-glazed, low-iron glass and wood, and will be naturally lit from an elaborately engineered roof incorporating wood beams, aluminum louvers and stretched fabric scrim and photovoltaic cells.

Piano clearly has the right stuff for this job. But it remains to be seen if he can actually deliver the goods. Ouroussoff, who was among the first to weigh in on the design, said “the biggest criticism is likely to be whether Piano is being too worshipful of Kahn’s genius”. But others, including Kahn experts David G. De Long and Robert McCarter, have expressed more pressing concerns about Piano’s pavilion, particularly the way it engages Kahn’s masterpiece.

De Long, who is professor emeritus of architecture at the University of Pennsylvania and co-author of “Louis I. Kahn: In The Realm of Architecture” (1991) a definitive volume on the architect’s work, said of Piano’s design, “It’s not fair to judge from the primitive visuals. Piano’s proposed addition seems respectful and keeps a certain distance, but I still wish it did not engage so directly with Kahn’s footprint — seemingly a reflection of its entrance façade and a bit too close to be read as a totally separate entity. Of positive note is the proposed route from the new underground garage, which will orient the visitors to the main façade in a way never before possible. A similar sense of extended symmetry comprised the addition to the Salk Center. It seems better here, but still not perfect. Like balancing the Parthenon with a parallel elevation.”

*Echoing some of the points made by De Long but with less optimism for Piano's design is Robert McCarter, the Ruth and Norman Moore Professor of Architecture at Washington University in Saint Louis and author of Louis I. Kahn, (2005). "Louis Kahn's Kimbell Art Museum is without question the greatest museum of the 20th century, and the proposed addition to it should be subjected to the most intense scrutiny, as was done in the 1980s when the addition, then proposed, was rejected as potentially 
damaging to the experience of the Kimbell. I am a great admirer of Renzo Piano, but in the case of the Kimbell
addition, I believe he is making a mistake”, McCarter said.

He continued, “The relationship of the Kimbell to the landscape to the west, an essential aspect of our experience of the museum, will not survive having a building, however minimally detailed, placed directly opposite the Kimbell's entry portico. I believe we should learn from irreparable mistakes such as the addition to Kahn's Salk Institute, set directly across from the entry to the central court, forever destroying the relationship between the court and the landscape of the approach.”

McCarter added, “I taught a studio project at Washington University three years ago for an addition to the Kimbell, using the site to the northeast, across from Ando's
Modern, and it was clear that, if the addition is not to touch the Kimbell,
that site works well. If we are to learn from mistakes, we should also learn from successes, such as Steven Holl's superb addition to the Nelson Atkins Museum of Kansas City, which despite the competition calling for a 
building set directly in front of the existing building, was added to the side 
of the original building – as would be the case with the southwest site for the Kimbell addition – joining the landscape garden by Dan Kiley to the original building”.

With construction soon to begin it is unlikely any amount of criticism will deal the project a fatal blow. But the Kimbell should at least provide sufficient enough time for others to weigh in. The objective now should be to protect the integrity of Kahn’s architecture as the museum grows in ways Kahn himself did not foresee.

Sharon McHugh
US Correspondent

*Editor's Note: Professor McCarter requested to amend his quote to correct a geographic error. The corrected quote appears above.

Key Facts

Status Planning
Value 0(m€)
Were you involved in this scheme?
Renzo Piano Building Workshop
www.rpbw.com

More projects by this architect

Harvard Art Museums

Kimbell Art Museum

Botin Centre

MUSE - Museo delle Scienze

Diogene

Visitors Center at the Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center

Harvard Art Museums Expansion

The Mortimer B. Zuckerman Mind Brain Behavior Institute

The View From The Shard

Academy Museum of Motion Pictures

Icon Project, Tjuvholmen development

The Shard of Glass

The Shard

The Shard

Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences Movie Museum

Landmark Tower

Chapel of Notre Dame du Haut Expansion

Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center

The Shard

Whitney Museum

The Shard

Resnick Pavilion, LACMA

Whitney Museum

Central Saint Giles

Valetta City Gate

Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum extension

The Shard

Central Saint Giles

Art Institute of Chicago Modern Wing

The Modern Wing, Art Institute of Chicago

Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center

Addition to the Kimbell Art Museum

Lynda and Stewart Resnick Exhibition Pavilion

California Academy of Sciences, Golden Gate Park

The Parco della Musica

EUR Towers

Whitney Museum of American Art

L &G and Mitsubishi Estate Company Building

Pacific Dawn

London Bridge Tower

Los Angeles County Museum of Art

 
Vola
ECOWAN
 

Click here to view the NEWS IN PICTURES tablet site