WAN Awards 2015


WAN Mobile
WAN Mobile
Previous Next

Columbia University Manhattanville campus, New York, New York, United States

Saturday 05 Dec 2009

Round two in town and gown dispute

Renzo Piano Building Workshop/SOM 
Your comments on this project

No. of Comments: 0

Add comments | More comments

Be the first to comment


Court limits Columbia University’s expansion into West Harlem 

An ambitious development plan that would allow Columbia University to expand its campus and its influence in the West Harlem neighbourhood of Manhattanville was thwarted today when a state court ruled that the procedure by which the University was to acquire land to build the project was unconstitutional.

In December 2008, the elite Manhattan-based college, which has maxed out its ability to expand on its Morningside Heights campus, unveiled a $6.3 billion plan development plan by Renzo Piano Building Workshop and SOM, for a satellite campus in nearby West Harlem. But to build the project, the University needed to acquire private property from owners who did not want to sell, forcing it to use the power of eminent domain to acquire the land. What the court ruled today is that the condemnation procedure by which Columbia was to acquire the land, which requires proof of public benefit, was in the interest of the University only. The ruling will stall the project if not also deal it a fatal blow.

Columbia, which controls 91% of the 17-acre parcel slated for development, could simply build around the privately held land that stands in the way of its development plans. But to do that would be difficult if not impossible. As currently designed, the area impacted by today’s decision calls for a below grade service core that would eliminate truck traffic at grade to better pedestrianize the site. To build this feature Columbia said it needs to control the entire 17-acre site.

The University plans to appeal today’s decision.

Sharon McHugh
US Correspondent

Key Facts

Status Concept design
Value 0(m€)
Were you involved in this scheme?

More projects by this architect

Cooper Hewitt Museum 2010 National Design Awards

Re-Contemplating the Void

National September 11 Memorial & Museum

2010 Pritzker Architecture Prize

RAIA 2010 Gold Medal

Bruce J Graham

Raimund Abraham,

Contemplating the Void: Interventions in the Guggenheim Museum

Broad Art Museum

Federation of Korean Industries Head Office

Forwarding Dallas

Rising Currents, New York

City Center, Las Vegas

Design It: Shelter Competition

2016 Olympic Village, Chicago

Julius Shulman

Re:Vision Dallas

Contemporary Art Museum at the Presidio

White Roofs

Burnham Pavilions

Guggenheim 50th Anniversary


Calatrava World Trade Center Transit Hub Exhibition

Plaza Program and Green Lights for Broadway

Museum of African American History and Culture

GSA Design Excellence Awards

Lieb House

Delft Faculty of Architecture

Coney Island Revitalization Plan

Ferrari Headquarters

La Sagrada Familia

Villa Villa

Port Authority Tower

Brooklyn Bridge Park

South Street Seaport Master Plan

Phoenix Art Museum Expansion

ASLA Green Roof

450 West 14th Street

Masdar Headquarters

Artek Pavilion

Atlantic Yards

99 Church Street Tower

Tour Carpe Diem

Liberty Hotel

Miami Art Museum

Hudson Rail Yards

Smithsonian Museum

Manhattanville redevelopment plan, Columbia University

Ian Thorpe Aquatic Centre

MGM MIrage CityCenter

Stone Hill Center, Clark Art Institute

Switch Building + Switch Gallery

Metal Shutter Houses

National Museum of American Jewish History


Nichols Bridgeway, Art Institute of Chicago

Transbay Transit Center

Kamraj Domestic Terminal Building at Chennai Airport

Seattle Art Museum

New Art Museum

Michael Lee-Chin Crystal at the Royal Ontario Museum

P.S. 1 Courtyard Installation

Ed Durell Stone Building

New Central Library for Pike County

Tor Vergata University

Nathan Phillips Square

Weisman Art Museum

Pavilion in Abu Dhabi

Columbia Memorial Space Science Learning Center

Nelson Atkins Museum Expansion

Regalia Holdings

The Olympic Sculpture Park

The Micheels House

Toledo Museum of Art

Museum of Contemporary Art

Rutgers University

Dallas Center for the Performing Arts

Museum Plaza

Yale University Art Gallery


Boston Tower

Museum of Contemporary Art San Diego

Kalahari Condominium Project

African American Cultural Center

North Carolina Museum of Art

Museum of the City of New York

Princeton University

The Museum of Modern Art

Denver Art Museum

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Orange County Performing Arts Center

Cornell University Milstein

University of Michigan


World Trade Centre


Click here to view the NEWS IN PICTURES tablet site